Lip Balm

24 February 2026

A string of deaths leads a pair of detectives on a hunt all over town. Their only clue? All the victims used the same drugged lip balm.

The Plot of the Show

Almost Plausible is a podcast where three friends make up stories, usually in the form of a movie plot, where something unexpected takes a central or critical role in the story. For example, how would you make a movie about a pillow? Or a ceiling fan? Or a toilet brush? That’s exactly what we try to figure out on the show!

Each episode starts with a brief pitch session, where we take turns sharing the ideas we’ve come up with for each episode’s topic. After we’ve heard all the pitches, we pick one, develop it, and hopefully come up with a story that’s at least almost plausible.

It's fun, funny, and it all happens in under an hour.

New to the show? Start here!

Not sure where start? The good news is that Almost Plausible isn't one of those shows where you have to start from Episode 1; you can choose any of our episodes and dive right in! Here are some of our favorites:

A-M-A-Z-I-N-G. My go-to podcast! Worth every enjoyable second to listen!

—zaaaayyaaaa

Previous Episodes

Glove

10 February 2026

While cleaning out the attic, a modern-day kid finds an old Nintendo Power Glove and is sucked into a video game world. Along with a cast of popular Nintendo characters, the boy must fight his way back to the real world.

Anchor

27 January 2026

Follow the antics of the ghost of a bumbling pirate captain as he annoys a New York couple after they buy the cursed anchor from his sunken ship.

Carrots

13 January 2026

While Emily is away, the boys will play. Mike and Ethan from The Other Half podcast join Thomas and Shep for a story about a woman who discovers a talking carrot in her fridge. Oh, and the carrot is French.

Meet the Crew

Three friends, one crazy idea, and a whole lotta fun! Meet the hosts of your new favorite podcast.